5 Characteristics of a Good Influencer

Reading Time: 10 Minutes

GRIN also recommends this free guide:

How to Find Influencers Guidebook

Download Guide

Why influencers are essential 

Influencers have revolutionized the way consumers discover, support, and engage with brands. But not all are created equal. In this blog, we’ll introduce you to the five most important characteristics of a good influencer so you get the best possible partners from your next campaign.

The top 5 characteristics of a good influencer

1: Authenticity

You can’t read an article about influencer marketing without a discussion of authenticity. And that’s for a good reason. While it’s easy to dismiss “authenticity” as mere marketing jargon, it has long been considered a key among successful and influential public figures, influencer marketers included.

“The public has a sixth sense for detecting insincerity; they know instinctively when words ring true.”

Bruce Barton, early 20th-century advertiser

Barton is expressing a fundamental truth in communications. Due to extensive exposure to commercial messages, modern audiences have been trained to continually evaluate what they see and hear for any signs of misinformation or inauthenticity. Those in the public eye who say one thing and do another, whether brands, public officials, celebrities, or even influencers, are subject to criticism, sanctions, or cancellation.

This effect may explain a great deal about today’s audiences’ overall level of distrust of media and traditional advertising. This modern-day commercial dynamic also amplifies the persuasive power of influencers, who, if they’re truly authentic, practice what they preach.

It’s this quality that makes influencers perfectly suited to the role of spokesperson, likely more so than celebrities, in fact. When evaluating product endorsements, consumers value relatability two times higher than the popularity of the spokesperson, one study found. Another 63% percent of polled consumers said they trusted the word of influencers over how brands portray themselves in messaging.

And they appear to be more persuasive than their real-life peers, as well, with influencers responsible for 94% higher sales compared to recommendations from friends and family.

2: Expert content creation

You don’t need an advanced degree or specialized training to become an influencer. However, to develop a sizable and authentic following, one must be able to produce content that stands out from the veritable ocean of content competing for consumers’ attention.

In developing, maintaining, and engaging loyal audiences, today’s influencers must master an array of disciplines—writing, photography, community management, project management, and marketingsynthesizing them into their distinct voice and perspective.

And while this content can be consumed almost instantaneously, its creation is anything but straightforward. Creating posts can take influencers anywhere from a few minutes to a few months, depending on the project. This includes work like location scouting, outfit selection and styling, hashtag research, writing, and rewriting copy with brand partners—all the way to the logistics involved in planning and organizing photo shoots.

“It’s easy to see a final YouTube video and to think that it looks so simple,” said Lucie Fink, a veteran influencer interviewed by Forbes. “But the actual act of putting a video together from start to finish is a full-on process that has taken me years to master.”

The result of this labor of love is some of the most skillfully created and well-targeted content on the internet.

When influencers are compared to brand-based content creation—in the broader industry of content marketing—the results speak for themselves.  According to a survey from the Content Marketing Institute, most (53%) marketers deemed their content marketing efforts “moderately successful,” with an additional 22% describing the performance as “minimally” successful. The top reason cited for poor performance: not having enough time to devote to content creation.

These results stand in contrast to influencer marketing, which proliferated in large part due to word of its explosive performance. One study found businesses using influencer marketing generated $6.50 in revenue for each dollar invested—only the bottom 18% of companies failed to generate revenue altogether.

3: Community management

Beyond cultivating their following, much of an influencer’s job is fostering an authentic relationship between them and their audience. Answering their followers’ questions, holding competitions, and managing passionate disagreements are all daily parts of the job.

Fashion influencer Elle Ferguson cites her time spent interacting with her community as responsible for her success.

“I always answer my DMs. That community has enabled me to build my brand. So I take probably three hours, morning and evening, to reply to my DMs on Elle Effect and Elle Ferguson because essentially they’re my customers – it’s so important to ensure that relationship is strong.”

-Elle Ferguson

Influencer marketing, above all, is based on the strength of the influencer-follower relationship. Authentic influencers like Ferguson take an active role in their followers’ lives, commenting, liking, and clarifying—all of it leading to a powerful bond.

4: Trust

Much like authenticity, maintaining trust between influencers and audiences is strictly necessary; good influencers are keenly aware of that. After all, trust guides our every decision, in the information we have faith in, the people we surround ourselves with, and also in who we trust to guide us through difficult decisions. 

Around 81% of polled consumers respondents said that they need to trust brands to “do what is right.” However, the same Edelman survey found that one-third of consumers purchase from many brands they don’t trust.

Trust is not only central to the influencer and audience relationship; it’s a necessity for this trust to extend to the brand/influencer relationship as well. That means providing audiences with transparency around sponsored content, being fair in product reviews and content, admitting one’s mistakes, and selectively approaching sponsors who fit with their audience and their needs, among other practices.

The consequences for breaking that trust is high, as anyone familiar with the celebrity apology news cycle understands intuitively. Forty-five percent of consumers polled in the above Edelman survey said they’d never regain confidence in a brand after unethical behavior, and 40% said they would stop buying from that brand altogether.

a good influencer making a video in an apron

5: Passion

If authenticity is the glue that binds influencers and audiences, then passion is the fuel. And much like authenticity, passion can’t be faked.

For their followers, influencers represent aspirational role models. Whether they pursue fashion, woodworking, home decor, or cooking—influencers allow people to watch relatable, likable people pursue their dreams and creativity right in front of them.

That’s why the passion, excitement, and creativity demonstrated by influencers are infectious and persuasive. Followers not only get to learn more about a passion of theirs; they’re able to follow along each step of the way, ask questions, share their stories, and even receive encouragement in their shared creative passion.

The best influencers can convey this passion equally in sponsored content and original content. And this passion needs to go both ways: to their followers and their brand partners. Without love for their field, influencers won’t find a following. And without a genuine interest or passion for a brand’s products, their campaign won’t benefit from the persuasive amplification that makes truly authentic influencer marketing so successful.

Key takeaway: What makes a good influencer ultimately comes down to authentic relationships.

At its best, influencer marketing appears effortless. To followers, the influencer relationship is intuitive, reassuring, and aspirational. To the brand, their relationship brings exciting new audiences. And it’s all made possible thanks to hard work, creativity, and a tireless commitment to authenticity.

Learn more about influencer marketing: Influencer Marketing 101

Updated: June 2024

Frequently Asked Questions

An influencer is anyone who can sway public opinion or action, typically through use of social media channels such as Instagram, Twitter, TikTok, and Twitch.

A content creator typically needs to have at least 1,000 followers or subscribers to be considered an influencer.

Influencers usually create content to share on social media, engage with their followers, and cultivate a community of like-minded individuals.

Was this article helpful? Give it a share!

Want to be the first to know what’s new in the creator economy?

Our team keeps a finger on the pulse, so you’re always working with the latest information.

Get the GRIN newsletter for all the trends and insights you need to grow your business.

Written by GRIN Contributor

GRIN is the pioneer behind the world’s first Creator Management platform built to support every brand’s journey to connecting with consumers through authentic creator relationships. Thousands of the world’s fastest-growing brands—including SKIMS, Warby Parker, Allbirds, Mejuri, and MVMT—use GRIN to make creators feel like trusted, empowered partners and work with them to build their brands into household names.

© Grin Technologies Inc. 2024. All rights reserved.

GRIN's Discovery Suite


Supercharge Your
Influencer Discovery Efforts

Discovery Suite

Supercharge Your Influencer Discovery Efforts

GRIN's NEW Discovery Suite

Discovery Suite
Compare the Time of a Manual Process vs. GRIN
Compare the Time of a Manual Process vs. GRIN
GRIN favicon

GRIN + Uber Case Study

How did one person build Uber's robust TikTok community from scratch?

Find out here
GRIN logo


Uber logo

Introducing GRIN
Professional Services

Our team of experts is ready to drive the results you need.

Learn more